Don Carlo. Ancora.

Jonas Kaufmann & Anja Harteros
Photosource

Some sweet soul has shared the Bayerische Staatsoper version of Verdi's Don Carlo on the Net. Eternally grateful. Completely made my day.

Watched the opening night live webcast little over a year ago, Jan 2012, if I remember correctly. Spellbound then and even more so now. Must have caught me on an extra-emotional moment today, such was the extent of the waterworks. Or maybe I just understood it deeper now. The first time most of the energy is usually spent on just concentrating on trying to make out what's happening. Especially without surtitles. And in a really foreign language like Italian. I so wish I knew more than your average culinary terms. Not much of an assistance on opera world ;)

Munich boasts a shining stellar cast for this Don Carlo. The title role of a disillusioned Spanish prince is sung by their very own superstar-tenor Jonas Kaufmann. Soprano Anja Harteros portrays Elisabeth, Princess of Valois, France, his love interest (and, incidentally, the king's, too, for that matter!). King Philip II is the ever-dapper bass René Pape, this time sporting a greyed do to heighten the age difference. The moving and motivating role of Rodrigo, Marquis of Posa, is sung here by baritone Boaz Daniel, though the original cast list would have had Mariusz Kwiecien onstage. He was indisposed at the time, sadly. Russian mezzo Anna Smirnova plays Princess Eboli, Elisabeth's opportunistic lady-in-waiting. The frightening and awe-inspiring role of the Grand Inquisitor is most efficiently boomed by an American bass Eric Halfvarson.

What struck me visually the most the first time I saw this Don Carlo, and even now, was how dark the stage is most of the time. You get used to it as the story goes on, and there are some brighter, or rather, more colourful moments. But as a whole, it is a very dark set. The stage is lit indirectly, light mostly coming from the doors to the sides and back. The only sources of light onstage are a few candles, and a pyre on Act 3, Scene 2. Much of the general absence of light is also due to the costumes being almost solely black. The Grand Inquisitor is just about the only character who has colour. His robes are of ecclesiastical purple. The King and Queen do wear red and gold ceremonially, but even their costumes have black as a base colour. This lightlessness is probably there to add to the general grave and gloomy mood of the piece. Point achieved. But couldn't the performers have had a tad more colourful or brighter outfits, if only to better distinguish them from the black background? Now it sometimes seemed that all I could see were floating faces and hands. Furthermore, the whole of Act One, the Fontainebleau scene, is staged under blue light. Deep in the forest? Night time? That's what it suggests. Ok, with gritted teeth, if it says so in the libretto. But the blue light makes distinguishing a tricky task and frankly does not really caress the features of even such beautiful people as Ms. Harteros and Mr. Kaufmann. A lot of rather unpleasant shadows.. Hmm, would have had second thoughts as a director / set designer (or whoever is responsible for them lights) on that.

Musically I have no complaints. Beautiful tunes. Splendid score. Lovely lines. Melancholy feel no doubt also strikes a special chord on Scandinavian ears. Like this very, very much. Might even be my favourite Verdi. The performers do well, too, especially the three principal ones.

Rene Papè & Eric Halfvarson
Photo: Bayerische Staatsoper / fotogallerie

Mr. Pape in his King's lament of unrequited love at the beginning of Act 4 ("Ella giammai m'amò!") is thoroughly believable and touching, and his bursts of jealousy ring true. The King is not really very likable a character. I mean, it's a dirty rotten thing to snatch away your son's fiancée. Couldn't help but wonder what's wrong with him. Where's his father's love? Is it because the Infante was of his previous marriage? Too painful to remember perhaps? Or is it rivalry, the young vs. the old? Reluctance to pass on the reign, to let go of the status? Or is he simply a pawn on a political game run by the Grand Inquisitor? There are glimpses of a better relationship between father and son, but then the King gets bullied by the church again and falls to his former ways. To his credit though, he does show emotion and remorse on his son's destiny in the end.

Ms. Harteros as Elisabeth did a compelling job. She may not be your absolute top of the litter actress expressively (one invariably feels she's holding something back), but boy she has a beautiful voice. Elisabeth's last act aria ("Tu che le vanità") was breathtaking in its exquisite sad tenderness and beauty. Lovely, lovely! Mind you, her somewhat demure stage presence seemed to fit well with the regal Princess/Queen. And her Act 4 swoon, after finding out it was the King who had the jewel case, was rather convincing. With Don Carlo, though, you'd have thought she'd showed a bit more heart and soul.. it was, after all, he who she loved. Or maybe it is just a case of growing pale in comparison to..

Mr. Kaufmann, then. Well, what can I say.. other than he spoils you rotten. Again. I suppose one has grown accustomed to him being superb. He never fails. His portrayal of the characters is always honest and true. It always seems well proportioned, he never gets over the top. There's hardly ever anything lacking and more than often he leaves the listener/watcher with abundant food for thought. World class. Top notch. Definitely. So is the case with Don Carlo, too. Extremely beautiful, utterly believable. The complex, torn and taunted Prince can't be the easiest to portray. I'm always a bit bewildered how come he so suddenly turns his attentions to politics and seems to forget Elisabeth. Which he, of course, after all does not. I think there's love and longing for Elisabeth till the very end even though he tries to soldier on with 'better' thoughts. He seems so perplexed and, frankly, lost. Holding on to the only tangible, plausible cause he can. Poor boy. 

Boaz Daniel & Jonas Kaufmann
Photo: Bayerische Staatsoper / fotogallerie

Back to singing.. Two of my favourite duets come from this opera: the powerful "Dio che nell'alma infondere" (Don Carlo and Rodrigo, Act 2) and the breathtakingly lovely "Ma lassù ci vedremo" (Elisabeth and Don Carlo, at the end of Act 5. Note! the link takes us to "È dessa.." when DC and E meet at Act 5, "Ma lassù.." starts at 06:41). The first always runs chills down my spine -good chills! not terrifying or bad ones!- for being so strong and heroic and potent. It's a battle cry for all causes good and worthy and a celebration for brotherly love. It gets you to stand up for your rights and crave for liberty. Messrs Kaufmann & Daniel version is slightly wavering rhythmically in places, but brilliant acting-wise. Love the touchy-feely warmth and Kaufmann's bewildered look at the end, where Rodrigo puts forth his hand and Don Carlo is hesitant whether to take it or not. "Ma lassù.." sends tears streaming down my cheeks, for being sooo beautiful and sad. Mr. Kaufmann and Ms. Harteros's performance is special to a tee. Very delicate and soft. Almost whisper-like. As if they're testing how soft a sound is still audible.. Spellbinding and very, very moving. And all the more effective while they are on the opposite sides of the stage, their movements as if mirroring each other. The best possible icing on the cake. 

Noticed that Don Carlo plays at Salzburg this summer. Starring Mr. Kaufmann and Ms. Harteros, Thomas Hampson as Rodrigo and our own Matti Salminen as the King. Sold out, of course, but when pigs fly.. and there were cancellations ;)